As you can see facts show that only 5 guilds in the world have thus far truly cleared ulduar, after all the time it's been released, it offers more then enough challenge.
Disregard anything the WoW-haters are screaming about it being casual, the facts clearly show that ulduar content is among if not THE hardest content in the game.
Alot of people can kill the bosses in Ulduar, this allows more people then ever before to enjoy raiding. The hard modes allow blizzard to give the challenge to the hardcore guilds, but also let guilds that don't have all that time and skill to enjoy the progression and lore, everyone wins.
Sir kyle is clearly just being a child atm and not willing to admit defeat. After being proven wrong he still claims it's to casual for his taste. He also says he left soon after ulduar was released, did he even kill normal bosses? He's not even done any hard-mode bosses yet, so don't take his word for anything.
The game is better then ever before and allows both the hardcore and casual players to enjoy the same game at the same time.
In any case, maybe if people played like they used to. (Lets count how many of Illidans guilds lost memebers who don't raid. Warpath, Blood Legion, Team Ice, Saga.. I can go on.) If people who had been there from the start we'd see this shit gonzo in no time at all. As if to prove my point, all my friends and myself included stopped with raiding and WoW a few weeks to a month and a bit after Ulduar's release. I also see people who were there for every encounter in BC and Vanilla wow also gone. (Ramalama for example) He just runs around shat in his T3 with Atiesh now, I saw him go to do things occasionally but not every night.
How silly do you have to be to really think that your little world sets the tone for 11 million players? This boss has been cleared by 5 guilds. Even a guild that was formed from 2 of the best guilds in the world (sure those players sucked right?) did not get it down till just this week.
This encounter is one of the hardest and most difficult fights ever, putting anything vanilla/TBC ever produced to shame. I mean god, Lady Vasjh died faster and that thing was bugged beyond reason. And here is a strong boss, no bugs, it's all you and your skill, and blizz allready said they ain't nerfing it. Just admit that you really didn't know what you were talkin about, because it's clear you don't.